Honest Shelf

Electronic shelf label in a Sydney supermarket
Photo: Maksym Kozlenko, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Food retail often slips into dark patterns: noisy discounts, fuzzy labelling, hidden sizes. Here’s a short, practical checklist to clean it up without killing margin.

What counts as a dark pattern

  • Price splitting: big “-30%” badge, tiny or missing unit price per 100 g/ml.
  • Fake anchors: “was £9.99” that never existed.
  • Health-washing: vague claims like “natural” or “farm fresh” with no criteria.
  • Hidden shrink: smaller pack, same packaging silhouette.
  • Tricky online flows: nutrition filters buried, sort-by-price resets on every click.

Rapid diagnosis (30 minutes per aisle)

  1. Select 10 top-selling SKUs plus 5 “healthy” alternatives.
  2. Audit shelf labels: unit price present and legible? last update date shown?
  3. Match site vs shelf: photos, descriptions and weights aligned?
  4. Walk the online path: filter → product page → basket. Note auto-adds or defaults you didn’t choose.
  5. Skim 5 recent customer complaints. Tag anything about price, size, or claims.

Better patterns

  • One honest price card: final price large; unit price per 100 g/ml alongside; last updated date.
  • One reason, one badge: either “Promo” or “New”, never both at once.
  • Nutrition visible by default: toggle pre-enabled; no extra clicks to see sugar/salt.
  • Clear language rules: ban fuzzy boosters unless criteria are linked from the label.
  • Stable sorting: if a shopper chooses “Price (low to high)”, keep it through filters.

Success metrics

  • Fewer price-related complaints and a higher shelf/site NPS.
  • Time-to-purchase steady or down, with bounce rate flat.
  • Share of “healthy” SKUs in baskets up while margin holds.
  • 30-day repeat rate for the category up.

Bottom line: an honest shelf is clear prices, transparent labelling and predictable flows. Trust grows. Friction drops.